Skip to content
immoriver
immoriver
Sign in Create account

Help · Contact · Imprint · Privacy

The big question

Buy or rent — what is in the account at the end?

Comparing instalment to rent falls short: the instalment repays debt, rent does not — but the tenant keeps their equity. This calculator compares the wealth of both households after years. The assumptions are sliders, not fine print.

“Buy or rent”, like every property calculator here, works without an account, without storage and without passing data to banks or brokers.

If you buy

If you rent

Same size and location — otherwise you compare two different lives.

Assumptions

1 to 1.5 % of the property value is common — more for old buildings.

Savings account 2–3 %, broad stock market 5–7 % before tax over the long run.

Better off at the end of the period:

Renting

After 20 years the tenant has €7,839 more wealth than the buyer.

Within 20 years the buyer does not catch up with the tenant.

  • Buyer's wealth €468,843 Value €594,379 − remaining debt €125,536
  • Tenant's wealth €476,682 Equity invested, plus what they save compared with the buyer
  • Monthly instalment €1,857 Rent at the end: €1,894
  • Buyer's total outlay €544,932 Total rent: €379,039

Wealth year by year

0 200 k 400 k 600 k 1 5 10 15 20 Year 1 – Buyer €66,828, Tenant €114,770 Year 2 – Buyer €82,415, Tenant €129,900 Year 3 – Buyer €98,498, Tenant €145,401 Year 4 – Buyer €115,097, Tenant €161,282 Year 5 – Buyer €132,229, Tenant €177,553 Year 6 – Buyer €149,915, Tenant €194,226 Year 7 – Buyer €168,175, Tenant €211,312 Year 8 – Buyer €187,031, Tenant €228,821 Year 9 – Buyer €206,504, Tenant €246,767 Year 10 – Buyer €226,619, Tenant €265,160 Year 11 – Buyer €247,398, Tenant €284,013 Year 12 – Buyer €268,868, Tenant €303,340 Year 13 – Buyer €291,053, Tenant €323,153 Year 14 – Buyer €313,983, Tenant €343,467 Year 15 – Buyer €337,684, Tenant €364,295 Year 16 – Buyer €362,186, Tenant €385,653 Year 17 – Buyer €387,521, Tenant €407,554 Year 18 – Buyer €413,720, Tenant €430,015 Year 19 – Buyer €440,815, Tenant €453,053 Year 20 – Buyer €468,843, Tenant €476,682
Buyer: property value minus remaining debt. Tenant: invested equity plus the yearly difference in outlay. All amounts nominal, before tax.
The numbers year by year
Year Rent / month Property value Remaining debt Buyer Tenant
1 €1,300 €408,000 €341,172 €66,828 €114,770
2 €1,326 €416,160 €333,745 €82,415 €129,900
3 €1,353 €424,483 €325,985 €98,498 €145,401
4 €1,380 €432,973 €317,876 €115,097 €161,282
5 €1,407 €441,632 €309,403 €132,229 €177,553
6 €1,435 €450,465 €300,550 €149,915 €194,226
7 €1,464 €459,474 €291,299 €168,175 €211,312
8 €1,493 €468,664 €281,633 €187,031 €228,821
9 €1,523 €478,037 €271,533 €206,504 €246,767
10 €1,554 €487,598 €260,979 €226,619 €265,160
11 €1,585 €497,350 €249,952 €247,398 €284,013
12 €1,616 €507,297 €238,429 €268,868 €303,340
13 €1,649 €517,443 €226,389 €291,053 €323,153
14 €1,682 €527,792 €213,809 €313,983 €343,467
15 €1,715 €538,347 €200,663 €337,684 €364,295
16 €1,750 €549,114 €186,928 €362,186 €385,653
17 €1,785 €560,097 €172,576 €387,521 €407,554
18 €1,820 €571,299 €157,579 €413,720 €430,015
19 €1,857 €582,724 €141,909 €440,815 €453,053
20 €1,894 €594,379 €125,536 €468,843 €476,682

Model calculation with simplified assumptions: constant interest rate over the whole term, no taxes, no selling costs, all amounts nominal. The result depends heavily on value growth and investment return — nobody knows either in advance. Default interest rate 4.4 %: Deutsche Bundesbank average for new housing loans with more than 10 years of fixed interest (4.13 % APR, 09/2026) plus 0.3 percentage points, because the example assumes 20 % equity and a correspondingly high loan-to-value; rounded. Not a loan offer — your terms depend on credit rating, equity and property; immoriver.com does not arrange loans.

How the comparison works

The buyer pays instalment and maintenance and owns the property at the end at its then value, minus remaining debt. The tenant pays rent, keeps their equity and invests it. If the buyer spends more per year than the tenant, the tenant invests the difference on top; if less, the tenant draws on the portfolio. What is compared is the wealth of both at the end — not who spent more.

The assumptions are the result

Two per cent more or less value growth shifts the result by six-figure amounts. That is not a flaw of the calculator but the truth about the question: whether buying pays off depends on things nobody knows beforehand. Whoever looks at the result under two or three different assumptions knows more than anyone handed a single number.

What is not included

Taxes (the tenant's capital gains, the tax-free sale of an owner-occupied home after ten years), selling costs at the end, rate changes after the fixed-rate period, inflation. And everything that cannot be measured in euros: security, freedom, willingness to move.

Frequently asked questions

Which time horizon should I choose?
As long as you realistically expect to stay. Below ten years renting almost always wins: the purchase costs are gone immediately and have to be earned back first. Stay 25 or 30 years and the repayment does its work. Try several horizons — the calculator names the crossover year below the result.
Why does the tenant get the equity as starting wealth?
Because they have it. The buyer puts their equity into purchase costs and price; the tenant keeps it. A comparison that ignores this takes the tenant's money away — and buying then always wins.
Which rent should I enter?
The cold rent for a comparable flat: same size, same location, same condition. The most common mistake is to set the cheap rent of a long-held flat against a larger house. That does not compare buying and renting — it compares two different lives.
What rate of appreciation is realistic?
Nobody knows, and that is the answer. Over the long run German residential property moved roughly in line with inflation, with long flat stretches, a strong decade up to 2022 and declines afterwards — with wide regional differences. Run it once with 0 %, once with 2 % and once with a negative figure. If the result flips, the question is not settled.
What return should I assume for the tenant?
The one you would actually achieve. Overnight deposits yield 2 to 3 %, a broadly diversified equity portfolio 5 to 7 % before tax over the long run — with swings you have to sit through. If the money would in truth sit in a current account, enter 0 %; the buyer then pulls ahead correspondingly earlier.
Why does only the buyer pay maintenance?
Because the tenant already pays it without seeing it: repairs to the building are the landlord's business and sit inside the cold rent. For the buyer the amount appears as its own line, because it hits them directly. Common figures are 1 to 1.5 % of the property value per year, more for older buildings.
Does the comparison assume a constant interest rate?
Yes, over the entire term — the biggest simplification here. In reality the fixed period ends after 10 or 15 years and the remaining debt is refinanced at whatever rate applies then. How strongly a higher follow-up rate bites is shown by the repayment schedule; here every figure would otherwise be an assumption about an assumption.
What does the crossover year mean?
The year from which the buyer holds more wealth than the tenant. Before that the tenant leads, because the purchase costs are gone at once and the early instalments are almost all interest. If it says the buyer does not catch up within the horizon, that is not an error — with high prices and moderate rents it is a common outcome.
Why are taxes not considered?
Because they depend on the personal tax rate and the type of investment. The tenant's capital gains are taxed at about 26 % (after allowance); the gain from selling an owner-occupied home is tax-free. Both tend to favour buying — by how much depends on the individual case.
What about selling costs?
Not included. Whoever sells at the end may pay an agent and has effort — realistically 3 to 7 % of the value. Whoever keeps the property pays nothing. Mentally subtract those costs from the buyer's wealth if a sale is planned.
Why is inflation not taken into account?
All amounts are nominal, on both sides alike — harmless for the comparison, because both fortunes would have to be reduced by the same factor. Inflation does matter in one place: it erodes the buyer's remaining debt while the tenant's rent rises with it. To reflect that, set the rent increase accordingly.
Is the result enough to decide?
No, and that is not a platitude. The calculator answers a money question. Not in it: the security of not being given notice, the freedom to change city next year, the effort of an owners' meeting, the feeling of being allowed to knock down a wall. For many people that weighs more than the final amount.

Further reading

Background: Buy or rent

Keep going

More calculators